Dormer vs. Mansard vs. Hip-to-Gable: Choosing the Right Loft Extension
1 February 2025

Expanding your home with a loft conversion is a smart way to add space and increase property value. However, selecting the right type of loft extension can be challenging. In this guide, we compare Dormer, Mansard, and Hip-to-Gable loft conversions to help homeowners in areas such as Kingston, Surbiton, Richmond, and Wimbledon make informed decisions.

Understanding Loft Extensions


Loft conversions are an excellent way to create additional living space without the need for a full-scale extension. Whether you want an extra bedroom, home office, or playroom, selecting the right type of loft conversion is essential to maximising your investment.


Dormer Loft Conversion

A dormer loft conversion is one of the most popular choices. It involves extending the existing roof to create additional headroom and floor space. The extension typically projects vertically from the sloped roof, forming a box-like structure. This type of conversion is suitable for most property types, including terraced, semi-detached, and detached homes. Additionally, dormer loft conversions allow for large windows, which enhance natural light, making the new space bright and airy.

While a dormer conversion is generally more affordable than other types, it may not be as visually appealing as a Mansard conversion. However, it often falls under permitted development, meaning planning permission is usually not required. The cost of a dormer conversion typically ranges between £40,000 and £70,000, depending on the size and specifications.


Mansard Loft Conversion

A Mansard loft conversion is an extensive modification that alters one or both roof slopes to create near-vertical walls and a flat roof. This design maximises the available interior space and is commonly found in urban areas, particularly on period and terraced properties. Mansard conversions offer the greatest increase in space, making them ideal for homeowners looking to create multiple rooms or a larger living area.

However, due to the significant structural changes required, a Mansard loft conversion typically requires planning permission. The construction process is more complex and time-consuming, resulting in higher costs, which usually range between £50,000 and £80,000. Despite the expense, many homeowners opt for a Mansard conversion due to its aesthetic appeal and the substantial space it adds to the property.


Hip-to-Gable Loft Conversion

A hip-to-gable loft conversion extends the sloping side of a hipped roof to create a vertical wall, increasing loft space. This type of conversion is particularly beneficial for semi-detached and detached properties with hipped roofs, as it provides more headroom and functional living space.

Unlike a dormer conversion, a hip-to-gable design alters the shape of the roof, which may require planning permission in some cases. While it is a more costly option compared to a simple dormer conversion, it provides a sleek, modern appearance that integrates well with the home’s exterior. A hip-to-gable conversion typically costs between £45,000 and £75,000.




Planning Permission & Building Regulations


In many cases, loft conversions fall under permitted development rights, meaning they do not require planning permission. However, this depends on factors such as the size of the extension and local council restrictions. Mansard conversions almost always require approval due to significant structural changes.

Building regulations must be adhered to, ensuring safety and compliance with insulation, fire safety, and structural integrity requirements. Homeowners should consult with a professional builder or architect to ensure all necessary approvals are in place before construction begins.




Choosing the Right Loft Extension for Your Home


Selecting the best loft conversion depends on factors such as property type, budget, and personal preferences. Homeowners in areas like Kingston, Twickenham, and Richmond should also consider the local aesthetic and planning regulations.


- A dormer conversion is a practical and cost-effective option for those looking for additional space without significant structural changes.

- A Mansard conversion, while more expensive, offers maximum space and enhances the home’s overall appearance.

- A hip-to-gable conversion is ideal for semi-detached and detached homes with hipped roofs, providing a seamless extension that blends well with the original structure.


Key differences:


  • Dormer:
  • A vertical extension projecting from the existing roof, often with a window. 
  • Can be added to almost any roof type. 
  • Considered a more cost-effective option. 
  • Mansard:
  • A roof design with two slopes on each side, where the lower slope is steeper than the upper. 
  • Creates a larger living space with more headroom compared to a dormer. 
  • Can significantly change the appearance of a house. 
  • Hip-to-Gable:
  • Converts a sloping "hip" roof section into a vertical "gable" wall. 
  • Best suited for properties with existing hipped roofs. 
  • Allows for more usable space by straightening one side of the roof. 


Loft Conversions types with associated prices


Why Choose HICL for Your Loft Conversion?


Home Improvement & Construction Ltd is a leading loft conversion specialist in South-West London, serving Kingston, Surbiton, Richmond, and surrounding areas. With over 20 years of experience, we provide turnkey construction solutions tailored to your needs. Our expert team offers bespoke loft designs, ensuring that your new space complements your existing home while maximising functionality.


At HICL, we take care of the entire process, from initial design and planning permission applications to construction and finishing touches. We use high-quality materials and craftsmanship to guarantee a durable and stylish loft conversion that adds significant value to your property.



Get a Free Consultation

If you’re considering a loft extension in Kingston, Wimbledon, or surrounding areas, contact HICL today for expert advice and a free consultation. Let us help you transform your home with a stylish and practical loft conversion.


Like what you see? Reach out to our experienced team, located in Surbiton.



Contact Us

Share this article

HICL Builders loft project in Avenue South, Surbiton
by Andi Drishti 24 October 2025
Discover how HICL Builders transformed a Surbiton home with a bespoke loft conversion, walk-in wardrobes, en suite and full K-render. Completed in 8 weeks.
Winter-Proofing Your Home: 12 Essential Maintenance Tips by HICL
by Andi Drishti 19 October 2025
Learn essential home maintenance tips by HICL to winter-proof your home. From draught-proofing, insulation, redecoration, and checking cracks to heating system upkeep, protect your home this winter while saving energy.
Open plan kitchen extension with 3.5 metre rear build and structural steels in Berryland
by Andi Drishti 16 October 2025
HICL Builders turned a split Berryland property into one family home with a 3.5 metre rear extension, open plan kitchen with pantry, and a new garage.
Loft Conversion Costs in Worcester Park 2025: Invest After Summer, Benefit in Winter
by Andi Drishti 13 September 2025
A loft conversion in Worcester Park can transform unused roof space into a stylish bedroom, a home office, or a playroom for growing children, while significantly adding to your property.
Loft Conversions for Victorian Homes in New Malden
by Andi Drishti 13 September 2025
In this guide you will find everything you need to know, written for homeowners in Surbiton, Kingston, Tolworth and Worcester Park who want a local expert that handles the whole journey with care.
Best Time to Start a Loft Conversion in Tolworth? Post-Holiday and Pre-Winter
by Andi Drishti 12 September 2025
In this guide, we explain exactly why this period works so well, what to plan for, and how HICL Builders delivers a smooth, stress free build that supports your family routine.
Planning a Loft Conversion in Kingston After Summer: Be Ready for Winter
by Andi Drishti 12 September 2025
If your home feels tight after the summer holidays, now is the perfect time to plan a loft conversion Kingston families can rely on. Autumn is ideal for design work, permissions, and early site preparation, so you can enjoy a warm, quiet, and beautifully finished space through winter.
Loft Conversions in Surbiton: The Smart Post Holiday Upgrade Before Winter
by Andi Drishti 12 September 2025
If you have just returned from summer travel and your Surbiton home already feels tight again, this is the ideal moment to plan ahead.
Loft Conversion in The Glade, Kingswood, Surrey from HICL Buillders
by Andi Drishti 10 September 2025
We recently undertook a comprehensive renovation and loft conversion project for Laurent and Claire, whose family was looking to modernise and enhance their wonderful property in The Glade, Kingswood, Surrey. The project involved replacing a leaky roof, updating all windows and external doors, converting the loft, improving insulation, and applying a new silicon render to give the home a fresh and contemporary appearance.
Modern rear extension in KT5, Kingston featuring white render, aluminium bifold doors
by Andi Drishti 10 September 2025
Discover this modern rear extension and garden transformation in KT5, Kingston by HICL Builders—featuring bifold doors, porcelain patio, and garden gym.